Hong Kong, often referred to as a dazzling beacon of finance and commerce, ranks as the third-largest financial center in the world and boasts the seventh-largest stock exchangeWith a staggering total market capitalization of \$45 trillion and foreign exchange reserves of \$421.4 billion, Hong Kong is a testament to its economic fortitudeThe city's GDP stands at a robust \$382.05 billionHowever, beneath this veneer of prosperity lies a perplexing conundrum: the Hong Kong stock market, particularly the Hang Seng Index, grapples with prolonged undervaluation, facing significantly low price-to-earnings (P/E) and price-to-book (P/B) ratios.

Recent data highlights that the rolling P/E ratio for the Hang Seng market has hovered around 10.45 times in the last decade, while its P/B ratio is a mere 0.94 timesIn stark contrast, other major global indices display considerably higher valuations

The Shanghai Composite Index presents a rolling P/E of 14.38 with a P/B of 1.52, while the Nikkei 225 boasts a P/E of 19.1 and a P/B of 1.78. The S&P 500, representing the largest single market index globally, shows a strong P/E of 23.86 and a P/B of 3.62. Newer contenders, such as the MSCI Mumbai Index, display even more exuberant valuations with a rolling P/E of 28.82 and a P/B of 3.78.

These figures starkly illustrate the extent of the undervaluation in the Hang Seng marketTo put this into perspective, the ten-year average valuation of the Hang Seng, with regard to P/E, is approximately 54.7% compared to Japan and 52.8% against the United StatesIf we consider P/B, these figures drop to an alarming 43.8% and 25.9%, respectivelySuch stark contrasts beg the question: what is driving the ongoing undervaluation of the Hang Seng Index?

Despite these figures, it is crucial to recognize that the Hong Kong stock market remains a significant channel for international capital to access Chinese markets

• ADP Employment Growth in December
• AI Glasses Take Center Stage at CES
• A50 Dive, US Stocks Open High but Decline
• Financial Firms Eye Year-End Bonuses
• Intel Drives into Automotive Ecosystem

It serves as a barometer for broader market expectations regarding the economy and key assetsThe low valuations are not merely numbers; they reflect deeper economic currents and challenges that need to be analyzed in context.

One fundamental factor influencing these low valuations is the link between the Hong Kong dollar and the US dollar, established under a fixed exchange rate system since 1983. This mechanism was designed to provide stability and mitigate currency risksHowever, it has significant implications for monetary policy autonomy and liquidity in Hong KongIn a world where capital flows are increasingly volatile, the rigid linkage can constrain the ability of Hong Kong to respond to local inflationary pressures or demand shocks.

Examine the implications: with the US dollar commanding the standards in monetary policy, any tightening in the US can amplify capital outflows from Hong Kong

This situation, compounded by the rise in inflation and the tightening of US monetary policy, creates a challenging environment for local businesses and investorsAs a result, market participants may view the local equities with escalating caution, particularly when compared to markets whose monetary policies may align more closely with their economic states.

Moreover, the capital structure of the Hong Kong stock market further complicates the situationThe market exhibits a tri-polar structure with foreign funds, local capital, and mainland Chinese capital forming significant blocsAs of 2023, international intermediaries hold about 39% of the market's value, while local intermediaries represent 38%, with Chinese intermediaries accounting for roughly 13%. The Capital Markets are heavily influenced by domestic participation—over 90% of initial public offerings stem from local or mainland enterprises

This dissonance between investor types can lead to significant mismatches in expectations and informational asymmetries.

This environment precipitates volatility, evident from the propensity for new shares to experience price drops immediately after listing, igniting fears of liquidity shortage and causing rational investors to hesitateThe streamlining of local financial intermediaries often fuels the 'Matthew Effect,' where top-tier corporations attract the majority of market liquidity, leaving smaller enterprises to languish without sufficient investmentSuch disproportionate liquidity can wreak havoc on market stability, as large corporations may become overly dominant, exacerbating disparities across sectors.

The reliance on traditional sectors—such as finance and real estate—further drags down overall market valuation

These industries, typically possessing lower valuations, make the broader market susceptible to economic downturns, impacting investor confidence and the perceived future performance of equities across the boardThis condition is reflected through heightened discount factors applied by institutions, which in turn depress their perceived value.

Additionally, the broader macroeconomic environment plays a pivotal role in shaping market expectationsThe prevailing backdrop of uncertainty has encouraged caution among investors, leading to a greater demand for value preservation rather than aggressive market entryInvestors may opt for hedging strategies, thus reinforcing trends of capital flight in response to shifting global economic indicators, further diminishing local equities.

There is a growing sense that the tide will eventually turn, influenced by an array of factors including internationalization of the Renminbi and re-synchronization of Hong Kong’s economic policies with mainland China

The eventual adjustments to the long-standing fixed exchange rate system could provide much-needed flexibility to Hong Kong, enhancing its competitive edge and potentially attracting a new wave of investment.

In the medium to long run, proactive adjustments in response to economic realities can bolster Hong Kong’s financial positioningThe evolution of the local economy, coupled with increasing absorption of sectors such as technology and healthcare, presents an opportunity to revamp its capital frameworkHistorical trends illustrate that the markets can, and do, correct under-compensation during more favorable periods.

In summation, Hong Kong's current predicament—where it thrives as a leading global financial hub yet faces systemic undervaluation—requires nuanced understandingThe delicate interplay of local dynamics, compounded by global market pressures, necessitates broader policy adjustments aimed at mitigating liquidity frustrations